Woman in workout attire

Do You Ditch the Briefs with Lined Shorts? A Closer Look

In the world of athletic wear, one question often leads to spirited debates: do you wear underwear with lined shorts, especially lined running shorts? This seemingly simple query reveals a complex array of preferences, practices, and even some health considerations. Let’s delve into this topic to understand the nuances and make informed choices.

Understanding Lined Shorts

Before delving into the decision of whether to wear underwear with lined shorts or not, it’s crucial to gain a clear understanding of what lined shorts are and how they function. This guide will provide detailed insights into the design of lined shorts and the considerations surrounding the use of underwear with them.

Lined shorts are a type of athletic or casual shorts that come equipped with an inner lining, often made of a soft, moisture-wicking fabric. This inner lining serves several purposes:

  • Support: The primary function of the inner lining is to provide support to the wearer. It can help reduce discomfort and provide stability during physical activities like running, cycling, or workouts;
  • Moisture Management: Lined shorts are designed with moisture-wicking properties, which means the inner lining efficiently absorbs and moves sweat away from the skin, promoting quick evaporation. This helps maintain a dry and comfortable environment, particularly during exercise;
  • Reduced Friction: The inner lining also contributes to reduced friction between the shorts and the skin, reducing the risk of chafing and skin irritation.

Arguments for Not Wearing Underwear

The decision of whether to wear underwear with lined shorts is a complex and widely debated topic, particularly within the realm of athletic and sportswear. Running shorts, gym shorts, and other sports attire frequently incorporate a built-in lining, sparking discussions that center on factors such as comfort, breathability, hygiene, and personal preference. Let’s explore the arguments in favor of not wearing underwear beneath lined shorts, shedding light on the pursuit of enhanced comfort, improved breathability, and design intention.

Comfort Enhancement

One of the central arguments supporting the notion of abstaining from wearing underwear beneath lined shorts is the quest for heightened comfort. Advocates of this perspective assert that forgoing underwear can result in an overall more comfortable experience, particularly during physically demanding activities like running, cycling, or strenuous workouts. This viewpoint is substantiated by the following key points:

  • Reduced Friction: The absence of an additional layer of fabric can significantly diminish the potential for friction between clothing and the skin. This reduction in friction not only minimizes the risk of chafing but also mitigates the likelihood of skin irritation and discomfort, enhancing overall comfort;
  • Freedom of Movement: Going commando within lined shorts allows for a greater degree of freedom of movement. The absence of the constriction typically associated with underwear provides individuals with increased ease and flexibility, qualities that can be particularly advantageous during activities requiring agility and physical exertion;
  • Lightweight Sensation: Many individuals harbor a preference for the lightweight sensation that accompanies wearing only lined shorts. The omission of underwear translates to the elimination of fabric bulk, contributing to a minimalist and unencumbered feeling, which can be particularly appealing during workouts and athletic endeavors.


Lined shorts are intentionally designed with optimal breathability in mind. They frequently feature moisture-wicking materials and strategic ventilation to ensure that air circulates freely, thereby facilitating temperature regulation and moisture management. Those who advocate against wearing underwear with lined shorts argue that adding an extra layer underneath has the potential to compromise this essential feature. Key points substantiating this perspective encompass:

  • Maximized Airflow: The inherent design of lined shorts is meticulously engineered to maximize airflow and facilitate efficient moisture management. The inclusion of an extra layer beneath the shorts, such as traditional underwear, may impede the free circulation of air. This obstruction can potentially lead to discomfort, especially in hot and humid conditions, where temperature and moisture control are paramount concerns.

Design Intention

Another persuasive point articulated by proponents of not wearing underwear is the argument that the built-in lining of these shorts is often explicitly intended to function as a substitute for traditional underwear. The lining is thoughtfully designed to provide the necessary support and coverage, aligning harmoniously with the specific design purpose of the garment. By adhering to this design intention, individuals may enjoy the advantages of the lining without the need for additional layers.

Arguments for Wearing Underwear

Woman in workout attire

This section will provide an in-depth exploration of the arguments in favor of wearing underwear with lined shorts, highlighting the importance of hygiene, the subjective nature of personal comfort, and the functional aspect of temperature regulation.


One of the compelling arguments in favor of wearing underwear with lined shorts revolves around maintaining hygiene standards. Advocates contend that underwear can play a pivotal role in keeping the shorts cleaner, as underwear is typically changed and washed more frequently than the shorts themselves. Key points supporting this perspective include:

  • Reduced Odor: Regularly changing and washing underwear can significantly minimize odor buildup within the lined shorts. This practice ensures a fresher and more pleasant experience, especially during extended use, such as during long workouts or outdoor activities;
  • Sweat Absorption: Underwear acts as a barrier that can effectively absorb sweat and moisture, preventing these elements from accumulating within the lined shorts. By trapping sweat, underwear helps maintain a dry environment, reducing the likelihood of discomfort or skin-related issues, such as chafing or rashes.

Personal Comfort

Comfort is an inherently subjective aspect, and individual preferences play a pivotal role in the decision to wear underwear with lined shorts. Some individuals simply prefer the sensation of an additional layer of underwear, emphasizing the perceived benefits of added support and coverage. Key points related to personal comfort include:

  • Subjective Preference: Comfort preferences vary widely among individuals. While some may find the minimalist feel of lined shorts alone appealing, others derive a sense of security and comfort from the added layer of underwear. This subjectivity underscores the importance of personal choice in the matter.

Temperature Regulation

The argument for wearing underwear with lined shorts gains additional weight in climates with colder temperatures or during cooler seasons. In such scenarios, underwear can serve as an additional layer of insulation and warmth, contributing to overall temperature regulation. Key points pertaining to temperature regulation include:

  • Added Insulation: In colder environments, an extra layer of underwear can provide valuable insulation, helping to retain body heat and maintain a comfortable temperature. This becomes particularly relevant when outdoor activities are pursued in chilly weather;
  • Functional Aspect: The choice to wear underwear in colder climates goes beyond personal preference; it becomes a functional consideration that directly impacts comfort and well-being in adverse weather conditions.

Health Considerations

When deciding whether to wear boxers with lined shorts or to go without, consider the following health aspects:

Skin Irritation

Skin sensitivity varies significantly from person to person, and it’s crucial to choose options that minimize irritation:

  • Fabric Selection: The choice of fabric for your boxers and lined shorts is paramount. Natural fabrics like cotton are known for their breathability and softness against the skin. On the other hand, synthetic materials may be less forgiving and can lead to more skin irritation, especially if you have sensitive skin;
  • Seams and Stitching: Pay attention to the construction of your boxers. Rough seams and stitching can chafe against your skin, leading to discomfort and even skin abrasions. Look for boxers with flat seams or seamless designs to reduce the risk of irritation;
  • Chafing Prevention: Chafing can be a common issue, particularly during physical activities or on hot, humid days. If you experience chafing, consider using specialized anti-chafing creams or powders. These products create a protective barrier between your skin and clothing, reducing friction and discomfort;
  • Personal Comfort: Whether you choose to wear briefs or brief liners is a matter of preference. Some individuals believe that wearing boxers underneath their lined shorts provides more support and avoids irritation, while others prefer the freedom and breathability of going without.


Maintaining proper hygiene is essential for overall well-being, and it should be a priority regardless of your clothing choice:

  • Managing Sweat and Moisture: Sweat and moisture can create an environment conducive to bacterial growth and skin issues. Whether you opt for boxers with lined shorts or go without, consider the following:
Moisture-Wicking MaterialsBoxers and lined shorts should be made of fabrics that pull sweat away from the skin, aiding evaporation and preventing skin irritation and bacterial growth.
Change PromptlyAfter physical activities causing sweating, changing out of sweaty clothes quickly is advised to avoid prolonged moisture exposure and reduce the risk of skin problems.
Antibacterial FabricsSome clothing brands provide fabrics with antibacterial or odor-resistant properties, which can maintain hygiene during intense workouts and help prevent bacterial growth.
  • Underwear Choice: If you choose to wear boxers with lined shorts, ensure that your boxers are clean, moisture-wicking, and in good condition. This extra layer can provide additional comfort and support, but it should not compromise hygiene.

Personal Preferences

Ultimately, the choice between boxers with lined shorts or going without underwear is highly subjective and depends on individual preferences:

  • Activity Level: Consider your daily activities and how they may influence your choice. For rigorous workouts or sports activities, you may prefer the added support of boxers with lined shorts. On more relaxed days, going without may be more comfortable;
  • Climate and Weather: Weather conditions play a significant role. In hot and humid climates, wearing moisture-wicking boxers with lined shorts can help manage sweat and discomfort. In colder climates, personal comfort and warmth may be more of a concern;
  • Experimentation: Don’t hesitate to experiment to find what works best for you. Try different combinations of clothing and pay attention to how your skin responds. Your preferences may evolve over time, and it’s essential to adapt to your changing needs.

Practical Tips

Woman in workout attire

When it comes to deciding whether to wear boxers with lined shorts or to go without, practical considerations can greatly impact your comfort and overall experience. In this detailed guide, we’ll provide you with practical tips and insights to help you make an informed choice based on your unique preferences and needs.

Trial and Error

Experimentation is a valuable approach when trying to determine what works best for you. Different activities and personal preferences may influence your decision. Here are some trial-and-error tips:

  • Activity-Based Testing: Try both options during various activities. For instance, wear boxers with lined shorts during a workout session, and then go without them on a less physically demanding day. This hands-on approach can help you identify which choice suits specific activities best;
  • Long-Term Assessment: Keep a journal or make mental notes of your experiences with each choice. Pay attention to comfort, skin irritation, and overall satisfaction. Over time, you’ll gather valuable insights into what works for you in different situations.

Material Matters

The choice of materials for both your boxers and lined shorts plays a pivotal role in your comfort and hygiene. To ensure a positive experience, consider the following material-related tips:

  • Moisture-Wicking Fabrics: Moisture-wicking fabrics are designed to pull sweat away from your skin, promoting quick evaporation. Whether you wear boxers or not, prioritize lined shorts made from these materials. They help manage moisture, reduce discomfort, and minimize the risk of skin irritation;
  • Breathable Materials: Breathable fabrics enhance air circulation, which can be especially beneficial during physical activities. Look for boxers and lined shorts made from breathable materials such as cotton, mesh, or performance blends;
  • Seamless Design: If you choose to wear boxers with lined shorts, opt for those with seamless designs. Seamless construction reduces friction and minimizes the risk of chafing, enhancing overall comfort.

Cleanliness is Key

Regardless of your choice between boxers and going without, maintaining cleanliness is essential for skin health and overall hygiene. Here are some cleanliness-related tips:

  • Regular Washing: If you decide not to wear underwear with lined shorts, it’s imperative to wash your lined shorts regularly. Sweating without a moisture-absorbing layer can lead to the accumulation of bacteria and odor. Follow the care instructions on your lined shorts to ensure they remain clean and fresh;
  • Underwear Care: If you opt for wearing boxers with lined shorts, it’s equally important to wash your underwear regularly. Moisture-wicking materials can lose their effectiveness over time if not properly cleaned, potentially compromising your comfort;
  • Hygiene Practices: In addition to washing your clothing, maintaining personal hygiene is crucial. Showering regularly, using antibacterial wipes, and practicing good genital hygiene can help prevent issues associated with sweat and bacteria.


The decision to wear underwear with lined shorts, including lined running shorts, boils down to personal preference, comfort, and individual health considerations. Whether you opt for an extra layer or enjoy the freedom of just your lined shorts, the most important thing is to listen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *